Books like 'Unlikely Reaper: A Short Paranormal Reverse Harem Romance Prequel'
Readers who enjoyed Unlikely Reaper: A Short Paranormal Reverse Harem Romance Prequel by Lacey Carter Andersen also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
paranormal fantasy reverse harem poly (3+ people) magic vampires shapeshifters demons
-
Absorbing Inevitability by Erin R. Flynn
Rated: 4.75 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsMy name is Tamsin Vale… And I don’t know who I am anymore. I only have the labels and titles. There are only the masks I wear to make it through the day and try to survive the pressure.And it’s killing me.Nothing is changing for the better, at least not for me. I’m doing so much to change the lives of millions, but there’s no improvement for me... -
Venery: A Why Choose Alien Romance by C.M. Stunich
I’ve been abducted by an alien in a cowboy hat.He needs me to play the role of fake fiancée to appease his family of tentacle-tailed cops.I’ll keep up the charade as long as I need if it means being reunited with Abraxas and Rurik.Shouldn’t be too hard, right? To play pretend …My life force is now inextricably tied to handsome, gun totin’ Officer Hyt...Categorized as:
vampires shapeshifters demons contemporary fantasy paranormal explicit-plentiful poly -
Vampire's Promise by Atlas Rose, Kim Faulks
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsHe captured my hand and kissed my palm. “If anything happens to me they’ll take care of you.” Tears shimmered in my eyes, like a damn burst inside me. A car crash finally igniting. He was the flames. They were all the flames. Burning inside me like a damn inferno. He stretched my arm over my head. I lifted the other in instinct, feeling his fingers grip my wrist... -
Hunger Pains by B.L. Brunnemer
Rated: 4.75 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsMy name is Lexie and I raise the dead. But Necromancy isn't all I can do. But that's for another time. It's my first week at the university and an accident has sent our world spinning. A decision that should be years in the making now has to be made in mere days. And the repercussions are big. And not just for my life but for the guys' as well. Everyone will feel my choice... -
-
The Rowan's Stone: An Urban Fantasy Reverse Harem Romance by Stella Brie
Arden's search for her destiny inadvertently revealed the true lineage of witches everywhere and a secret history hidden long ago. Now, she needs to find the meaning and purpose of the Rowan. With questions piling up and a parchment stingy with answers, she must look to the past before she can embrace her future... -
Exploring Fae by M. Sinclair
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsMy name is Maize.Poisonous to the touch.The bastard child of one very dead Dark Fae King.A refugee of a war that freed me from my three-year imprisonment.Eager to explore a kingdom that while not welcoming, could hold everything I’d ever dreamed for. Hope. Hope for a real future. That was if someone didn’t kill me first, due to their hatred of what I represented... -
Loving Nightmares by M. Sinclair
Rated: 4.52 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsI would go to war to protect the nightmares I loved. War was at our doorstep threatening to kill my father, and with him were enough humans that if battle ensued, it would make national headlines. Ones that would only further divide and enhance the hatred between humans and nightmares.War had to be defeated, I just didn’t know how... -
Tea Time with the Dead by M. Sinclair
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsI hadn’t been wrong about the trouble I’d felt brewing. Now, the problem was here to stay unless we could figure out a plan. A plan to stop Nero from trying to take New Orleans from me. A plan to stop Asmodeus from kidnapping me to the demonic realm. Hell. A plan to figure out what I was going to do about these six men in my life... -
Smoke and Wishes by A.J. Macey
Rated: 4.24 of 5 stars · 28 ratingsWhat do you do when your whole life is a lie? Go to college... I just found out that I’m a supernatural and now I’m attending Redwood Supernatural University. With its magic and mix of beings from myth and legend, I’m definitely not in the human world anymore. But not everything is picture perfect... -
The Last Vessel by Winter Rose
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 13 ratingsI thought that the hardest thing I would have to face this year would be Trial Month. Gods, I was naïve. My name is Luna Moon. Don’t ask me what I am, because complicated doesn’t even begin to cut it. I recently found out that everything I knew to be true has been a lie. Including who I am... -
Forever and Ever Omen by Ashley Amy
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsPLEASE NOTE THIS IS AN EXTENDED EPILOGUE. Sometimes, we don’t except the curveballs thrown at us. With recent revelations, we faced a whole new battle. One that wiped the board clean and reset the game. Even with all our pieces at the ready, I feared we might lose. Give me a blade, a bad guy to kill, and I will. That’s easy for me. What isn’t? Someone calling me Mommy... -
Elizabeth and the Magic of Dragons: A Reverse Harem Paranormal Romance by Ava Mason
Rated: 4.43 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsAn ancient book destroyed. A kingdom threatened. A Reverse Harem Paranormal Romance. Elizabeth travels to Aerwyna with her four dragon protectors, a magical place she didn't know existed, where dragon shifters live out in the open. During their journey to find the legendary wolf with dragon offspring, a rare and ancient book was destroyed... -
Fractured Souls by M. Sinclair
Rated: 4.67 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsLorcan's fractured soul will save everyone . Note from The Tears of the Siren series will feature characters from both the Reborn series and the Descendant series. It will not be necessary to read either of those to understand the plot, however, they do intertwine in a way that enhances the universe... -
Succubus Blessed by Heather Long
Rated: 4.57 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsIf I told you, that would be spoiling the last book. I know, I know. Not everyone likes secrets, but that's half of the fun of telling my story. I'll tell you when the time is right. Promise.The following blurb might contain spoilers for Succubus Unchained. Be warned before you scroll down.There might be something to this new life of mine.Being mated to Maddox and bonded to Alfred isn’t so bad... -
-
Forgotten Fairytale by Yumoyori Wilson
Rated: 4.57 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsWhat if your life was like a forgotten fairytale? Would you cry in despair at losing the memories of a story you held so dearly? Or move on to start a new chapter, deciding to accept your fate? That's exactly how I feel about my current dilemma as I face this new world. My name is Mako, code name: Bloody Butterfly... -
Psychos by M. Sinclair
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsI had thought the hard part was over.Mario was dead and my vengeance achieved. However, the past was still causing problems, namely in the form of the Light Fae. Yeah... them. Remember how I am supposed to be getting married to their True Heir? That wasn't going to happen. I needed to find a solution and fast before my guard loses it... -
Cheating Death by Sarah Reynolds
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsThe last thing Sunday Prescott wanted to do was rescue her brother from another problematic adventure, but that is exactly where she ended up.When Colton found himself in the holding cells of the Ruby Star Casino, Sunday knew that the only way to get him out what to appeal to the casino's owner... -
The Rowan's Destiny by Stella Brie
The Rowan's destiny is to power the stone and save the magic of witches everywhere. Or is it?When the words of the past reveal new secrets, Arden must decide which path to follow—the one dictated by others, or the one designed by her.From the ballroom to the battlefield, Arden and the Imperium Cadre discover an intricate web of deceit and a massive abuse of power... -
Academy of the Elites: Unbound Magic by Alexis Calder
Rated: 4.35 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsRaven survived the trials with her wolf shifter, sexy billionaire twins, and the demon prince by her side. But it’s not over. Not by a long shot. Another Fae got through the portal the night Raven and her men stopped Professor Halifax. He’s after something Raven has, and he’ll stop at nothing to get it. On top of that, the school board decided the first trials didn’t count... -
Academy of the Forsaken by Eva Chase
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsWhen I arrived at Roseborne College searching for my foster brother, I had no idea what I was in for. In the past few weeks, I've endured torments both physical and emotional. I've looked death in the face. And I've made an unnerving discovery that's left me scrambling to pick up the pieces of the quest I started out on.But the supernatural beings who run this school haven't conquered me yet...Categorized as:
demons magic shapeshifters fantasy legends & fairy tales suspense new adult paranormal -
Buttercup by Helen Scott
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsLife is sweet, especially for a baker whose life is about to turn upside down...Take one shy baker, add one sexy bartender, a moody prison guard, an actual demon, and a man who is more mystery than anything else, then add two helpings of curiosity, one night of Long Islands and bad decisions, a steamy romance novel, and abandoned inhibitions. Mix well and wait for the fun to start... -
Pack Possessed by J. Kearston
Rated: 4.60 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsYou can’t outrun your demons, but you sure as hell can give them a run for their money. The monster that’s tormented us from the shadows has finally stepped into the light, and he has his sights set on me. But discovering that my entire life has been orchestrated as a twisted form of training to help him literally unleash hell on earth? Not exactly my idea of a romantic gesture... -
Daniel by Yumoyori Wilson
Rated: 4.60 of 5 stars · 5 ratingsMy name is Daniel Moore — a healer, star knight, and lover. I'd never had any ambition to become a stronger healer. I'd rather sleep all day, than train like my fellow knights, using the excuse of being an angel shifter and having no problem healing a few cuts and bruises. I couldn't imagine a time where my skills would be worth the time and effort...until now... -
Dead Wolf Falling by Rory Miles
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsDon’t let the darkness consume you. Easier said then done when facing off with death. I was so close to escaping and making it back to Aunt Lou, but my heart got in the way. Now I’m trapped inside of an academy full of ghosts who want to consume me. I have seven days to claim my harem and defeat the evil spirits before we’re all dead... -
-
Freeing Fae by M. Sinclair
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsMy name is Maize.Poisonous to the touch.The bastard child of one very dead Dark Fae King.A refugee of a war that freed me from my three-year imprisonment.Captured by one of the monsters that haunted my nightmares each night. I may have been free, but I would never forget the torture I’d gone through at the hands of my father’s guard. It seemed they hadn’t forgotten either... -
Fortuna Academy Box Set Books 1-4 by J.B. Trepagnier
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsThe Complete Fortuna Academy Series, Available in one boxed set. Hayley Killoran was not ready to find out she was the daughter of Lucifer and a powerful witch. Lucifer was not ready for one of his brothers to stage a hostile takeover of Hell. Hell was not ready for Hayley Fortuna Academy is an adult reverse harem Academy series with one snarky female and five fated mates... -
Dying for the Dead by M. Sinclair
Rated: 4.43 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsMy mission? To save New Orleans from Nero’s demonic clutches. Should be simple, right? I mean, hell, I am literally the Queen of the Dead. I fear that we are running out of time though.Time to save the missing supes taken by Nero and Asmodeus.Time to get out of the Demonic realm, before we can’t leave.Time to save our city and my kingdom.The biggest snap in my plan? I’ve died... -
Master Juggler by Erin R. Flynn
Rated: 4.43 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsGoing undercover with a fake name to solve murders, shut down bad clubs, and punish people is a ridiculously difficult job even with a team to support her. Using two covers in LA to play the bad guys from both sides to take down an abduction ring using lust demons as sex slaves and getting to the bottom of problems at the club just might get Jasmine Stewart killed...Categorized as:
vampires shapeshifters demons heroine sleuth mystery paranormal suspense reverse harem -
Poisonous Dream by Yumoyori Wilson
Rated: 4.43 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsDon't you sometimes wish that everything was just a dream?My name is Daniel Moore, future heir of Realm Ten, ArchAilennia.I've never felt regret like this before, such turmoil clinging to my very soul. I had vowed once long ago to never endure such pain and torment. Yet, such a vow has already been broken and this time, it's to someone far more dear.My princess is everything to me... -
Reckoning: A Reverse Harem Tale by Dakota Brown
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsAfter rescuing me from the Andersons, my men are dreaming of a bloody revenge. Me? All I want is to be left alone long enough to work through finals and enjoy my free time with the boys who love me so much.But we can't find peace until the Andersons are gone. I have the knowledge I need to fight back, but the enemy still has an ace in the hole... -
House of Fae and Mist: Brides Selection by Meg Xuemei X
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsI have no intention of being anyone’s bride, let alone fighting tooth and nail to get there.All the vicious catfights in the school nauseate me. I have bigger things to worry about, like being hunted by my father, who’s getting closer every day.Yet no one leaves me alone. The princes believe I’m playing hard to get, so they pursue me fiercely... -
Vampire Visions: The Chronicles of Sloane King by M.F. Adele
I am not a good person. I may have lied about the “occasional murder spree” bit, but I did say it was justified, right? It totally is, I swear. Over the last week countless heads have rolled, mine included. I got stuck in my feelings, and I may or may not have punched my ex in the face after saving his life. He deserved it though, he said it himself. All of my mates are now living under one roof... -
A Crown Of Smoke And Ash: A Reverse Harem, Paranormal Romance by Sloane Murphy
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsAfter having my life turned upside down, I discovered past me had left more than one thing that needed fixing.Past me was awesome.Saved by an angel, protected by him and the three other men I love, I learn there's more to the mystery of my past lives than I ever could have realized.With danger around every corner, I try to realign a world gone awry... -
Forbidden Bond: A Reverse Harem Paranormal Romance by Fiona Starr
Rated: 4.17 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsThey’re the ones in power, so why are they are so afraid of me? Newly minted magic user? Check. Hot-as-hell boyfriends who want only me? Check. A fresh start after surviving a murderous attack? Yeah, about that… They said choosing a life at Stormwood Academy wouldn’t be easy. But nobody mentioned it would make me a target... -
-
Wicked Game: A Reverse Harem Paranormal Romance by Sadie Moss
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsI really thought we had it. We were so freaking close.But you know what they say about counting your demonic portals before they’re closed.Now we’ve got dozens of the stupid things to deal with, and my angelic superiors don’t seem all that concerned about the literal hell that’s about to be unleashed on Earth... -
The Price of Exorcism by Dakota Brown
Rated: 4.19 of 5 stars · 13 ratingsI was an exorcist, one of the best. When things got hot, I got out. I wasn’t fast enough, and I ended up with nothing but my parents’ old pizza parlor.Then my ex-best friend Darius wandered back into my life needing my skills. Innocent lives were in danger and I couldn’t say no. That dragged me deeper into the occult than I ever thought possible, and I can’t see a way back out... -
Demon's Touch: A Reverse Harem Tale by Dakota Brown
Rated: 4.18 of 5 stars · 13 ratingsThe only thing more dangerous than being a mage is other people knowing that you have supernatural abilities. And here I am, untrained, untried, and ripe for the picking. With the magical black market chasing my untrained powers, I'm running a race I can't win. The wolves who have added me to their pack are no match for the dark mages hunting me... -
Their Rejected Mate: A Rejected Mate Werewolf Romance by River Ramsey
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsMy three intended mates left me rejected, half-marked, and broken.Every wolf shifter dreams about her first night with her mates, but mine left me an outcast with the revelation that I'm really a hybrid. A hybrid between a wolf and what is the question. Only my late mother knows the answer, but these days, I have other things to worry about... -
Queen Takes Darkness 2: A Their Vampire Queen Novel by Joely Sue Burkhart
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsEscaping the Darkness is only the beginning…Catapulted by her newfound power, Helayna Ironheart escaped the endless darkness of Hel to the human world. She even managed to free her three guardian Blood from their stone gargoyles by giving them her blood. But escaping the infinite coils of the world serpent is only the beginning of her journey through Darkness... -
Wicked Awakening by Sarah Piper
A witch with no power captured by four vicious, possessive, sinfully hot gargoyles…Not exactly the makings of a happy ending.Yet here in the arms of New York’s most brutal monsters, I’ve never felt so safe. So cherished... -
Shay's Acceptance by Bre Rose
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsMav We hit her! Who the fuck was she running from? Two wolves, a vampire and a fae. Then those dreaded words, she’s not breathing. We‘ve come so close, I can’t lose her now before we reconnect. What does this mean for my child, the one I never knew existed? If she survives, how do I explain who she is, what her role is in the prophecy that could bring the end to all supernatural beings... -
Wrath of the Gods by Eva Ashwood
Rated: 4.29 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsEverything I’ve been told about the gods and magic is a lie.I wanted answers. And, holy shit, did I get them.But now all I have are more questions and a bunch of powers I don’t know how to control.After the shocking revelation that left me reeling, I’m left questioning everything about myself. But at least there are three men who still believe in me... -
Juniper: A paranormal reverse harem comedy by Eva Delaney
When my dark magic meets a spelled book, my favorite adult toys turn into…three hotties?!I made an enemy of my allies when I stole a few items that weren't necessarily mine. Now that I'm being hunted, romance isn't in the cards... -
Reaper Hospital: Code Possessive Boss: A Paranormal Reverse Harem Romance by Lacey Carter Andersen
Rated: 4.29 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsWhen I died, I didn't expect to be reborn as something evil.Now I'm undercover at a busy hospital as a healer. I'm called a miracle worker by some and a scam artist by others. The truth is, they're all right about me. I'm not technically a healer. I'm a reaper.The kicker is, I've found a way to heal by using my powers of death, something no reaper has ever done before... -
-
Starlight Christmas - Holiday Edition by Yumoyori Wilson
Rated: 4.29 of 5 stars · 7 ratingsChristmas. A time for giving and receiving. A time for celebration. A holiday I’ve only read about in a storybook – page after page of seeing a little girl celebrating the joys of Christmas. I had envied that girl, reading her tale on the cold, library floor while she was surrounded by so much warmth...Categorized as:
shapeshifters magic demons reverse harem paranormal fantasy strong heroine christmas -
Institute of Unpredictable Magic #1-3 by Sadie Moss
Rated: 4.29 of 5 stars · 7 ratings**This complete, steamy reverse harem series is ready to be devoured!**Dangerous intrigue, forbidden passion, and ominous magic. And that’s just on my first day.As the newest recruit at the Institute of Unpredictable Magic, I’m determined to prove I have what it takes to be part of this elite team of supernaturals who protect the magical community... -
Transfuse by Maya Nicole
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsI'm not who I thought I was.With five men at my side, can I defeat the threat to Inferna?Can I face who I am and what I have become?And the most important question... do panthers like catnip?Transfuse is book three in the Infernal Council series. It is a continuation of Infuse and Defuse. This novel is full length and reverse harem. It contains multiple POVs... -
Blood Bound by Harper Wylde
Rated: 4.22 of 5 stars · 9 ratingsEverything is different now—including me. Turns out I’m not a witch after all. I’m shadow touched, a rare breed of supernatural with the ability to fight off demons and keep the mundane world safe. And the cherry on top? The fate of the mortal realm lies solely in my hands... -
Demon Demands: The Chronicles of Sloane King by M.F. Adele
I am not a good person.I'm definitely a liar and a murderer, but this time "justified" isn't going to cover it. I will level the entire f*****g realm if I don't get back what's mine.The roller coaster that is my life has veered off course and is plummeting head first off a steep cliff. I can't decide if I should keep my eyes open and watch my impending doom or shut them an hope for the best... -
Hellfire by J.B. Trepagnier
Rated: 4.18 of 5 stars · 11 ratingsNew enemies, new allies. I survived my first year at Fortuna Academy. Lucifer met my mates and it wasn’t totally mortifying. I met Azriel’s mom and she’s not that bad. We’re all back at school and we have a mission—find that prophecy and figure out who tried to poison Keane. Everyone in our group has a least favorite Hellhound they suspect of doing the deed, but really, we have nothing...
Fantastic book recommendations by romance book lovers for romance book lovers.
Find out more about romance.io.
Find out more about romance.io.
Get recommendations by genres & tropes
Use the romance book finder to mix and match over 100 content keywords to find the books that match your preferences
Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.